With Chiwetel Ejiofor, Nicole Kidman, Julia Roberts, Dean Norris. When all else is false, … Michael Haneke's "The White Ribbon," another considerable film, was thought to be the front-runner.The academy did a good thing when it reformed the foreign-language film voting, requiring all voters to see all five finalists. The story of the Argentinian-Spanish film is magnificent and the cast of "Secret in Their Eyes" is top-notch. "Secret in Their Eyes" is a dark remake of the excellent Oscar winner "El secreto de sus ojos" (2009). The Secret in their Eyes is an amazing film starring Julia Roberts, Nicole Kidman, and some other guy playing Ray. Despite the confused screenplay, the result is a film not comparable to the original but worthwhile watching. Secret In Their Eyes Trailer Sends Julia Roberts Down Horrible Rabbit Hole. The film is a joint production of Argentine and Spanish companies. My vote is seven. Directed by Billy Ray. The Secret in their Eyes is an amazing film starring Julia Roberts, Nicole Kidman, and some other guy playing Ray. Verdict. On paper, Secret In Their Eyes is straight out of a pulpy detective novel. The Secret in Their Eyes movie reviews & Metacritic score: Recently retired criminal court investigator Benjamin, decides to write a novel based on a twenty-five year old … It is a must see. As said before, it’s a powerful story with amazing direction and a talented cast. Secret In Their Eyes is a dark and disturbing psychological thriller. See more » There's a loose-cannon investigator who's way too close to a murder case. The story of the Argentinian-Spanish film is magnificent and the cast of "Secret in Their Eyes" is top-notch. The Secret in Their Eyes (El Secreto de Sus Ojos) Critics Consensus. Overall, The Secret In Their Eyes is a fantastic movie. The reviews were really bad, and so I was a bit worried. Despite the confused screenplay, the result is a film not comparable to the original but worthwhile watching. Like in the original The Secret in Their Eyes (2009), the role played by Julia Roberts was initially earmarked for a male actor, but director and screenwriter Billy Ray rewrote it specifically for the actress. Julia Roberts, Chiwetel Ejiofor and Nicole Kidman star in Secret in Their Eyes, a thriller without thrills. It is at number five of my top ten of 2009, and a movie that I would love to watch again and again. But that’s exactly what you get with Secret in Their Eyes, the latest film starring Julia Roberts, Nicole Kidman, and Chiwetel Ejiofor. “Secret in Their Eyes” also requires Roberts, who is kept at bay through much of the movie save for several showy outbursts and the twist ending, to turn down her star wattage considerably even before she is grief-stricken. The only reason Secret in Their Eyes is able to hold one's attention for any amount of time is its jumping back and forth between 2002 and 2015. It seems these films are a lost art of yesteryear.